Lovely Shade, but a Bit Smudgy
"This liquid lipstick shade coordinates well with the colours in the Beyond the Grave: Haunting Hour palette (which I'm wearing on my eyes in the attached photo of my Halloween costume this year), and it applies nicely. I wish it stayed better and had a more crisp finish once dry. It lives up to the "velvet" in the name, but not so much the "grip," I'm afraid. I don't think anything will be able to beat Killstar's Coven Cosmetics "Dusk" matte liquid lip that they discontinued a few years ago and I miss VERY much. Anyway, of the other liquid lips in this particular crop, "Ember Pit" in the metallic finish has MUCH better staying power than "Doomberry" and doesn't transfer or smudge as badly. I'm not sure why or how, since I am not a chemist, but not all the colours in this particular drop were made equally."